
There was cool debate going on my Facebook page between two friends from totally different backgrounds. It started after I posted a news article about a young woman 27 years old who had sex with a dude who was 17 years old. Does everyone believe this is really wrong I wrote. It was concensual sex. This is most likely only a crime in the United States. In England the age of consent is 16, in France 15 and in Italy 14. Similiar in most European countries. I am not taking sides, just pointing out a fact.
This is what the news article said, "Alexandra McLean, a 27-year-old former theater teacher at Englewood High School, has been arrested for an alleged sexual relationship with a 17-year-old male student. McLean is being charged with two counts of sexual assault on a child by a person in a position of trust, 7News reports.
The 17-year-old victim and McLean are believed to have met each other during the production of a high school play at Englewood High School, CBS4 reports. McLean would occasionally drive the victim home from rehearsals and in McLean's car is where they allegedly wound up having sex together somewhere around Nov 15. and Nov. 16, according to The Denver Post."
Here is a re-post of the debate on my Facebook page:
Quinn Santouryou Shepherd: I can see where they are trippin because he isn't 18 but how can a woman 10 years older than him be charged with sexual assault?! That makes no damn sense.
January 6 at 12:11pm · Like.
Tom Carlstrom: pedofile
January 6 at 12:57pm · Like.
Debbie Maier Pillon: I disagree Phil. It's wrong for a person in a position of power to have sex with an under aged student.
If roles were reversed..... a young woman and older male teacher we would all be upset.
Teachers
Doctors
Coaches
Should not abuse their power.
January 6 at 1:21pm · Like · 2.
Steven Munoz: GODDAMMIT WHERE WERE THESE HORNY ASS TEACHERS WHEN I WAS 17???
January 6 at 2:10pm · Like.
Steven Munoz: And Tom, a pedophile goes after children. At 17 you're well past childhood.
January 6 at 2:11pm · Like.
Debbie Maier Pillon: Steven do you have a daughter?
January 6 at 2:17pm · Like.
Steven Munoz: No, but I do know where you're going with this so let me explain that double standard: In our mating behavior initiation is traditionally done by the male, most times via manipulation, deception, what have you. I'm taking it as safe to assume that in this case the boy hit on the teacher, and since women at her age tend to start questioning and downplaying their attractiveness, she eventually gave in to his pursuits. Had it been the other way around it's more inclined to be seen as sexual assault, because knowing how our male brains work, he worked up to it. Of course that's not always the case either.
January 6 at 2:23pm · Like.
Steven Munoz: And besides, biologically speaking, we're sexually active by the ages even young as 13. So despite societal points of view or what the law has to say about it, it only comes natural.
January 6 at 2:24pm · Like.
Debbie Maier Pillon: If so I wonder if you would be so quick to call her a free sexual thinking woman.
I would call the teacher a manipulating criminal.
January 6 at 2:28pm · Like.
Steven Munoz: What father would? Instinctively any man (who isn't a sack of shit) would jump to protect his daughter from things like that, but you can't call it so easily because there's two sides to every story like that. For example if she were the high school hussy then it'd be more clear.
January 6 at 2:30pm · Like.
Debbie Maier Pillon: Steven please explain 27 yr old women and the "downplaying their attractiveness". I'm not questioning the age as much as the relationship. It's 2012 and women initiate sex just as men do. To assume that this 17 BOY came on to this 27 yr old women, and because she feels unattractive she eventually "gives in" to his advances is just plain stupid.
She's a professional and took her power and had sex with a student that she had power over. I know for a fact that teachers are given training on this, and she knew better.
January 6 at 2:47pm · Like.
Debbie Maier Pillon: And to answer your question..... The teachers were around when you were 17 they just had more class than to hit on you.
January 6 at 2:49pm · Like.
Steven Munoz: I was into some of my teachers at that age and had I been bold enough, I'd have tried the same thing, and to add to that generalizations don't apply because as I said, every case differs. One thing I can say for damn sure is that this boy wasn't assaulted. It's difficult enough to achieve an erection consensually, so explain how he would have managed under pressure.
January 6 at 2:50pm · Like · 1.
Debbie Maier Pillon: Because he was able to preform doesn't mean he wasn't groomed for the act.
Assault doesn't only mean held down against your will.
January 6 at 2:57pm · Like.
Steven Munoz: I call bullshit on that one.
January 6 at 2:58pm · Like.
Steven Munoz: http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/assault
Assault - Definition and More from the Free Merriam-Webster Dictionary
www.merriam-webster.com
Definition of assault from the Merriam-Webster Online Dictionary with audio pronunciations, thesaurus, Word of the Day, and word games...
January 6 at 3:01pm · Like · .
Debbie Maier Pillon: What the hell is the High School Hussy???
Does that mean if you had had more courage as a 17 yr old high school student you would have approached your female teachers for sex.
Would your parents have been ok with that?
If this was my son I would make sure she was charged with assault and not teach again.
January 6 at 3:09pm · Like.
Steven Munoz: My dad sure as hell would have haha. If it was your son I'm sure he would have protested such an action and you being his parent would assume the authoritative position and said something in the tone of "You're too young to know what you want." But in actuality, being only about 7 years past that age, I still remember that being what I would have wanted at the time. What else do you think a boy that age is gonna think about when he's in his room "studying" lol. And really? You've never heard that phrase? I'm surprised because it's rather tame for people my age. Well basically it's the girl that everyone gets a shot at. Not the most dignified of lifestyles, but they do exist.
January 6 at 3:15pm · Like.
Debbie Maier Pillon: person who is incapable of giving consent (as because of age.
Thank you for proving me right.
17 is not the legal age to give consent.
January 6 at 3:15pm · Like.
Steven Munoz: Legality has nothing to do with it. A 17 year old boy is capable of making logical decisions, and as all humans do, we choose what benefits us most, whether gratified immediately or down the road.
January 6 at 3:18pm · Like.
Debbie Maier Pillon: Ok so everything aside do you really think school is the appropriate place to silicate sex??? Especially a teacher and under age student.
You are right about that.... I would help my son with authority. Sounds like your father would advise you to get what you can from that woman. At 24 I'm sure that's what you still think. But at 34 an 44 you should revisit these thoughts.
January 6 at 3:27pm · Like.
Steven Munoz: That's quite a way to twist what I said into something malevolent. No, I don't think sex should be solicited in school from teacher to student. We got that enough from the girls our age growing up. But if it happens it happens. It's an isolated incident in the case of the parties involved. And no I don't think he would. I think it would have been a case of an "Atta boy" and a beer.
January 6 at 3:35pm · Like.
Steven Munoz: And to explain the double standard again in the case of sons and daughters and men and women: If a key can open any lock it's a master key. If a lock opens up to any key, then it's a shitty lock.
January 6 at 3:41pm · Like.
Debbie Maier Pillon: Phil's post originated with the legality of consensual (age) sex. U.S being 18 vs. other countries. If you want to talk about 17 yr old young men and their desires, and all consuming thoughts then I agree with you. Boys at that age do have a One-track mind. By your theory it's ok as long as the natural desire is there. Civilization works by laws rules, not feelings and desires.
January 6 at 3:43pm · Like.
Debbie Maier Pillon: Double standards....... I hope you give more thought to this subject when you advise your future kids.
January 6 at 3:58pm · Like.
Philip Liborio Gangi: I am glad I got a healthy discussion going. That was my intent. Thank you Steven and Debbie.
January 6 at 4:18pm · Like.
Steven Munoz: And laws are not always right such as marijuana prohibition and restricting the drinking age to 21. How many of us have followed that as well?
January 6 at 4:26pm · Like.
Philip Liborio Gangi: What is interesting also is that it is legal for a female minor to get an abortion without her parents consent, but a 17 year old dude cannot legally even date a 19 year old girl.
January 6 at 4:39pm · Like.
Debbie Maier Pillon: There is a difference between drinking a beer that concerns your own body and an older person of power talking you into having sex with them.
We were talking about this particular teacher and her crime against this young man.
Yes Phil, it's been a good conversation.
January 6 at 4:41pm · Like.
Steven Munoz: Actually Phil I dated a 17 year old when I was 19.
January 6 at 4:41pm · Like.
Steven Munoz: What crime?? She let him fuck her and gave him what every 17 year old wants: Pussy
January 6 at 4:42pm · Like.
Debbie Maier Pillon: You just crossed the line. I do not appreciate your mouth.
Discussing a news topic is fine, but speaking like a piece of trash is not ok.
January 6 at 4:57pm · Like.
Debbie Maier Pillon: Done
January 6 at 4:58pm · Like.
Steven Munoz: It's called honesty. I hold my tongue back for no one.
January 6 at 4:59pm · Like.
Debbie Maier Pillon: Done.
January 6 at 5:00pm · Like.
Steven Munoz: Maybe you should get over your outdated prudish point of view and face the reality that people can't be controlled by trivial institutional ideals like laws and so called common morals. We all live by our own sets of morals. Some violate the sanctity of others but it's a fact of life we must live with.
January 6 at 5:01pm · Like.
Debbie Maier Pillon: Speaking to people like trash is not the only way for honesty. I'm not prude, I respect others and their opinions. However..... Your langue isn't about being honest. I find when people turn to profanity it's because they have run out of logic. Seems to be true in this case too.
Enjoy your evening.
January 6 at 5:10pm · Like.
Steven Munoz: Defaming another for petty reasons is trashy. Cursing is mere words. The language I'm speaking here is English. Taking the high road is meaningless as long as the message is conveyed and you're focusing on menial irrelevant things. I haven't run out of anything because I still stand by my statements and my arguments are perfectly sound. If I haven't convinced you of my point of view, that's fine by me, because I know what I know and I've taken the time to analyze and rationalize the topic by negating what the drones of society perceive as "the norm" by basing their ideals on what authority dictates us to believe as wrong.
January 6 at 5:14pm · Like.
Debbie Maier Pillon: Right.
January 6 at 5:20pm · Like.
Debbie Maier Pillon: Lots of words..... Good for you.
January 6 at 5:21pm · Like.
Debbie Maier Pillon: I recognize the English langue....and petty drivel. Lots and lots of words. Good for you and your opinions of societies drones.
January 6 at 5:24pm · Like.
Debbie Maier Pillon: I choice to protect my children when given the opportunity. Including telling them a mature sexual relationship is NOT with their teachers.
January 6 at 5:26pm · Like.
Steven Munoz: By their teenage years theres nothing you can do to "protect" them. They discover things of this nature on their own. Am I saying it's right? No. But it is a natural occurence between sexually mature beings. Like I said, childhoods over by late adolescence. Maybe if you were able to see between the black and white you'd have an easier time understanding my point and this conversation would have ended much sooner.
January 6 at 6:09pm · Like.
Yvonne Pingatore: key words 'position of trust'
January 6 at 8:16pm · Like.
Kathleen Ponsiglione-Gray: Omgosh...she looks really young & there are some "kids" that dont look as young as they are in high school. Its up to the adult to do the right thing for the student...legally it was wrong, psychologically? Wrong. He should be with girls/friends closer to his age. This was just for the sex it seems, that isnt a good lesson for all who become familiar with this case. Values. Respect. It should be going both ways.
January 7 at 12:10am · Like · 1.
Steven Munoz: That's a more solid way to put it. I still see he idea of him as a victim as ludicrous though.
January 7 at 12:27am · Like.
Debbie Maier Pillon: That's because that was Your fantasy. You've said it several times. Who's thinking is close now??? You cannot imagine being labeled a victim for getting exactly what you want. You assume this young man is you.
BTW not all 17 yr old boys can handle a sexual relationship.
January 7 at 8:27am · Like.
Steven Munoz: Well he clearly couldn't, seeing as how he was stupid enough to brag about it to his buddies. Victimization requires infliction of pain and actual damage, so to lump an adult woman who has consensual sex with a near legal teenager in the same category as someone who prowls the street to snatch up a little boy to sodomize him in the locker room shower is absurd.
January 7 at 11:16am · Like.
Steven Munoz: And that's not my "fantasy" in particular. Ask any man or boy had it been him with a teacher he found appealing and he'll most likely answer yes or no with a subtle smirk afterward.
January 7 at 11:35am · Like.
Kathleen Ponsiglione-Gray: I got to comment with you two...you both make good, honest points. Mamas are very protective of their children and want to make their world right. I have to tell you though its like steven says...i think the youngsters are trying out their wings. I'm a short woman and for some reason many assume that makes me young i guess. I've had "to young" kids, teenagers come on to me! Want to talk about weird, I just laugh or pretend like i dont hear it. Now the white hairs slow 'em down ;) parents need to talk to their children about responsibility & sticking with their peer group
Sunday at 3:46pm · Like.
Philip Liborio Gangi: Great discussion here. I wish my friend Eve who is a teacher in England would jump in.
Sunday at 3:52pm · Like











